Soft tissue complications of the surgical treatment of unstable fractures of the ankle: is it timing of the surgery or the implants?

S. Yousaf, C. Lee, A. Khan, N. Hossain, M. Edmondson

¹Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust, Brighton, United Kingdom

Introduction: Early stabilization has the potential to expedite early return to function and reduce hospital stay thus reducing cost to health care. A clinical audit was performed to test the hypothesis that early surgical stabilization lowers the rate of soft tissue complications and is not influenced by choice of distal fibular implants used for stabilization of ankle fractures.

Methods: All surgically treated adult patients with isolated unstable ankle fracture were included from April 2012 to April 2013 at a MTC in UK. Patients with poly-trauma were excluded. All patients underwent a standard surgical protocol: aim for early definitive surgical fixation (ORIF) within 24 hours however if significantly swollen than temporary stabilization with an external fixation followed by a staged definitive fixation.

Results: In total 172 consecutive unstable ankle fractures were included in one-year study period. Definitive fixation (ORIF) was achieved in 91% patients with only 9% patients required temporary stabilization with external fixation. Fibular locking plates were used in 59(38%) patients compared to conventional one-third tubular plates in 91(60%) patients. In ORIF group 42% (73) patients were operated within 24 hours of admission whilst 58% (83) under went early fixation after 24-72 hours. At one year follow up complications were recorded in 18(11%) patients including metal irritation requiring removal of implant in 6(4%) patients. Wound complications and deep infection leading to a further surgical procedure in 8(5%) patients. There was no statistical difference between complication rates (p=0.016) in early versus delayed fixation groups. Fibular locking plates were associated with higher soft tissue complications (13%) as compared with conventional plates (2%) (p=0.004).

Conclusion: Our study showed that the timing of the surgery has less influence on the complications of the ankle fracture fixation. However choice of implants requires careful consideration and we suggest caution against use of current fibular locking plates.

Click thumbnail below to view poster / thumbnail: